In this article, you’ll learn about the best deer attractants on the market so that you can find the one that best fits your needs.
You’ll also learn how to choose an attractant and what to look out for, but if you are in a hurry you should just choose one of the top three. They are my favorite deer attractants; I have tested them and they are proven to work.
Are you ready to find the perfect deer attractant? Then let’s get started.
1. Whitetail Institute Imperial Clover
- Packed with ANTLER-BUILDING protein
- Helps does deliver HEAVIER, HEALTHIER fawns and produce more...
- EXTREMELY cold tolerant - Heat, drought and disease...
The first of the attractants we’ll check out is Imperial Clover by Whitetail Institute. Clover is relatively easy to grow, and it is loaded with nutrition such as protein, fiber, calcium, iron, vitamin C, and folate. Plus, bucks simply love it!
Interesting fact: The Whitetail Institute started the production of clover seeds in 1988 and has been the leader in this field ever since. You can’t go wrong with the right name for the product.
There are hundreds of specialized food plot mixes on the market today, and most of them perform as advertised. But, when it comes to a day-in-day-out food plot performer, it’s hard to beat a suitable plot of clover.
It might be tempting to save a few bucks and find a cheaper option in the local feed and seed stores. However, I do not recommend it.
Much of the clover sold by agricultural feed stores is designed to be baled up and fed to livestock. Long, tall clovers look good in the field, but they contain a high percentage of the stem-like material, and whitetails do not digest it that well.
Another thing to consider is the ratings. The Imperial Whitetail Clover has 4.5 out of 5 stars, and the customers just love it!
For example, one of the buyers, Product King, said, “This product is amazing! I recently purchased a property that has 4 1/2 acres of woods. I set up a clearing and used Whitetail Institutes herbicide products and soil test (highly recommended). After waiting a few weeks, I tilled up all the dead grass and weeds and spread down the clover. Within DAYS the clover was sprouting! The deer are going nuts. I have set up a game cam on the food plot and several times a day I get bucks, does and fawns grazing on the plot. It is amazing!”
- Fast to grow
- Bucks love clover
- Cold and heat tolerant, drought and disease resistant
- Lasts up to 5 years from a single planting
- Cold and hot weather extremes slow down growth
- May require approval from local authorities
2. Whitetail Institute Imperial Winter-Greens
- MORE ATTRACTIVE to deer than any other brassicas tested by...
- FORTIFIED with a small amount of Whitetail Institute's tall...
- Highly nutritious LATE SEASON food source
Depending on the part of the country you live in, the deer food plot either loses its attraction or becomes covered with snow during the winter season.
Therefore, everyone, from the amateurs to experienced hunters, knows that in order to continue luring deer, you must have a large supply of quality food. Otherwise, wildlife animals will just stop coming.
And that’s precisely why, if you don’t live in Southern states, you should consider buying winter-greens from Whitetail Institute.
Deer are just like humans in some ways. They love sweets, yet need their greens. So, this product solves both problems: As the weather gets colder, the greens become sweeter, because brassicas by nature sweeten with a hard frost.
Not sold? Let’s see what other people have to say about it.
Firstly, let’s take a look at the ratings. It’s got 4.2 out of 5 stars on Amazon!
A buyer with the username “I won’t steer you wrong!”, even stated, “I planted this 6 days [ago] and it’s already growing well. I did do a quick tilling of the lawn/yard and it’s still a little clumpy. I was a little worried that it wouldn’t take so well, but it’s going strong, even with the flock of 16 turkeys that walk it daily. I did a little under a 1/2 acre and I had just enough seed to complete it.”
High in nutrients
Easy to plant
May require approval from local authorities
3. Whitetail Institute Imperial Tall Tine Tubers
- Includes Tall Tine Turnip - a NEW TURNIP VARIETY genetically...
- TWO FOOD SOURCES - foliage above ground and tubers...
- EXTREMELY drought and cold tolerant - Establishes and grows...
Turnips, just like winter-greens, are in a group of plants called brassicas. They are incredibly high in protein and easily digestible in the deer gut system.
What’s incredible about turnips and brassica plants in general is that unlike cereal grains, the amount of fiber does not increase. This means that these plants are easily digestible for deer throughout the time of growing.
However, be aware: Deer rarely eat the leaves when they are not fully developed. Instead, they wait until the tops become more mature because young leaves tend to be bitter. Then, when the heads grow bigger, they become way sweeter due to the conversion of starch into sugar.
Whitetail Institute is competent and thriving in the area of brassicas. They spend lots of time researching in order to create the most genetically advanced formula.
But don’t just trust me, let’s take a look at the reviews.
The rating of this product is 4 out of 5 stars. Not only that, but many people are pleased with their purchase.
For example, customer Karen S says, “I planted these in late October just before a rain. I didn’t even follow the cultivating instructions. I just sowed them on top of some pine needles and grasses and they came up quickly. The deer are already rooting in them and they are not even mature enough yet. I wish I had planted them about 4 weeks earlier.”
Easily digestible by deer in any time of growth
Drought and cold tolerant
Establishes and grows quickly
Without rain, the chance the turnips are going to grow is much lower
May require approval from local authorities
3. Buck Jam Honey Acorn
- Buck Jam is a gooey gel-like mineral lick that is jam full...
- Deer are attracted instantly to the Buck Jam site, where...
- The intense aromas attract and are reinforced by a flavor...
This option is fantastic for those who don’t want to put too much work into attracting deer. Were you looking for an easy solution? Well, here it is!
Buck Jam Honey Acorn is considered to be one of the best liquid products for attracting deer. It is a liquid formula that includes molasses and acorn flavors.
There are several positive things about this product.
First, this attractant contains lots of fat and calories to give bucks more energy. Second, Buck Jam Honey Acorn works well all year long. And third, it targets almost all types of deer, including whitetail deer.
And the most important thing is that you can pour it anywhere, from plants to the ground.
Even though the rating of this product is just 3.7 out of 5, that doesn’t mean it’s terrible. Those who left positive reviews seem very enthusiastic about it!
For example, Amazon customer Donna S. says, “Our family just loves to feed the deer in our backyard and I decided to buy some of this to pour on their corn for a little treat. Well, we went from having only two deer in our yard… to 13 at once. This is amazing stuff and the deer really seem to love it. When we ran out, I tried finding it locally and couldn’t find it anywhere. So this will be a regular order from now on for us.”
Easy to use
No need to plant anything
Can be used on any surface
Not all deer recognize it
May attract bugs and ants
4. Wildgame Innovations Acorn Rage
- Acorn Rage was strategically developed to be both attractive...
- This concentrated formula is ready to use right out of the...
- Place directly on ground, in trough feeders or free-choice...
Acorns are quite popular among deer, even though they don’t contain that much protein. Even so, acorns are full of carbs and fats.
Plus, deer quickly digest them and absorb the nutrients, which means they can eat lots of them on a daily basis. Deer consume lots of acorns in order to get the amount of protein they need.
That is the main reason why Acorn Rage is considered to be the best attractant in wooded areas, as acorns grow naturally there.
It contains high levels of protein and fat, which stimulates deer’s appetite and improves the quality of the meat.
What’s more, this product strengthens and accelerates the growth of antlers as well as improving their digestive system.
Acorn Rage can be used throughout the entire year. However, it works way better either in the fall or winter, when acorns naturally fall from the trees.
This product has 4.1 out of 5 stars, and people are more than happy with it.
For example, one of their Amazon customers, Mario, stated, “This is an excellent product for attracting deer. It’s not magic and has to be used properly. I find the best time to use this is December-January, after the rut and when food is scarce. I place a large pile out a few days before hunting to allow deer time to find it. Once discovered keep the pile supplied and they will come back. I also place a “row” of acorn rage across a known deer path within shooting range of my stand/blind. I don’t put this out if rain/snow is coming and I try to be aware of other hunters baiting close by. I use Acorn Rage in NJ where baiting is legal.”
Incredibly attractive to deer
High in nutrients
Improves deer health
5. Deer Co-Cain BlackMagic
This attractant is for people who don’t want to spend time planting brassicas. Deer Co-Cain BlackMagic contains phosphorus, calcium, and sodium, which naturally lure deer.
What’s more important, it doesn’t require any mixing. Sure, you can add ingredients if you want, but it’s not necessary as the formula is already complete on its own.
Another significant advantage is that this product can be used throughout the whole year. So, you can lure big bucks into wide-open areas any time you want.
Now you might ask, what about the smell of the product? Interestingly, the scent stays for an extended period of time and is able to attract deer from a long distance.
If you use it in open areas, this product will significantly increase the chances of luring bucks. The scent imitates a woody aroma, plus has a pleasant taste that does not irritate the deer’s senses.
This deer attractant is an excellent product that keeps them comfortable without making them agitated in any way.
This product has 3.5 out of 5 stars on Amazon, and customers are delighted with it.
For example, one of the buyers, Gymrat, says, “This stuff hands-down beats regular deer cocaine by a long shot. The black licorice smell allows the deer to find it overnight. Plus, unlike regular deer cocaine, BlackMagic has calcium, something bucks and does needs. Specifically, during the spring and summer for antler growth and fawn development. Great stuff and highly recommend.”
No need to mix or plant
The formula is easily digestible by deer
Can be used throughout the year
The mixture is easily damaged in the rain
6. Buck Stop Natural Skunk Deer Scent
Whitetail deer are naturally fantastic at detecting faint odors, as this ability helps them to stay alive. Researchers at Mississippi State University found that a deer’s sense of smell, like a dog’s, can be anywhere from 500 to 1,000 times more acute than humans’.
No need to argue, deer’s nose is its most significant aid in survival.
So, when an animal has such an extraordinary ability, what do you do in order to trick it? One of the oldest tricks is to play the wind and practice scent control while hunting. Years before scent elimination sprays, hunters relied only on skunk cover scent.
Buck Stop Natural Skunk Deer Scent is one of the best products of this type on the market. Its main goal is to cover the human scents (but take in consideration that it also overwhelms human noses), so that deer do not become alarmed.
This product has 4 out of 5 stars. Plus, customers have left many positive reviews!
For example, Amazon customer DF said, “I was a little skeptical about buying this, but I think it works great. I just started hunting and got winded a few times. I was told skunk is one of the best covers sent to use. I used it on a few different occasions and the dear never even knew I was there! I use a q-tip to apply it to my boots to help cover my sent as I’m going to my stand. When I store my gear, I put it in an airtight tote and I never smell it in the house. I store the bottle of scent inside a mason jar with paper towel stuffed inside to store it and stop it from breaking.”
Covers human odors
The wax sealing prevents scent from wearing off
One bottle is more than enough for the whole hunting season
Need to be very careful as the smell is very strong
7. HME Scent Lab She-Heat
- She heat scent web is a patented scent, wick and a delivery...
- The Magnum propulsion from scent web will shoot a web up to...
- Because this is an aerosol, there are no messy liquids,...
One of the top odors to use as an attractant is HME Scent Lab She-Heat. It produces a coating that creates a sweet apple smell over anything it’s applied on. Deer are way more interested in eating things when they are covered in this beautiful scent.
This type of deer attractant provides the buck with a slight bit of energy, allowing it to keep on moving and stay active.
Scent Lab She-Heat coating can also travel along with a slight breeze. It can go up to a quarter of a mile on a three-mile-per-hour breeze. Therefore, it produces an intense trail of smell that does not extend too far yet creates a scent deer cannot resist.
What’s more interesting, this spray works even better when it’s raining or snowing. This is one of a few scents with a stronger effect when the weather isn’t great.
And probably the most crucial part is that Scent Web is an environmental-friendly spray that can be up to 300% more potent than liquid scent products.
This spray has 4.1 out of 5 stars, and customers are in love with it.
For example, one of the buyers, Viper1, mentioned, “Have used this product in the past but have been unable to find it near my area. It is quite potent so be careful not to get any on your clothes or gear. Rain or snow seems to strengthen its effect. Works especially well when used with mock scrapes. First time I used this, a nice buck came right up to the branches I sprayed it on. Lasts longer than the “Buck Bomb” but on a windy day, the Buck Bomb may cover more area especially if activated from a tree stand.”
Easy to use
Odor lasts for days
Need to be extra careful not to get it on the clothes
8. Antler King Honey Hole Mix
- Fast growing and easy to establish
- For best results plant in late summer or early fall.
- Comprised of 5 varieties of Rape and Turnips, 3 lb. bag...
Honey Hole mixture is the right choice if you’re willing to plant brassicas but don’t know which one to choose. This mix includes five different types of brassicas, three of which are varieties of rapeseed, and two are different varieties of turnips.
The best time to plant it is in the spring or summer. The most exciting part is that you’ll be able to see the first results in the late fall or winter!
After the first frost, brassicas transform stored up starches into sugar, which gives energy to bucks. These are just irresistible to deer.
Because these plants thrive with little to no tilling, anyone can plant this mix without equipment. So, if you’re looking for an easy way to grow several types of brassicas, then this is your go-to option!
If you combine this with a good crossbow and a great crossbow scope, I expect you’ll get a fun and exciting hunt.
This mix has 4 out of 5 stars, and the customers seem very happy with it.
For example, buyers Matthew Epps said, “I planted this mix the last two seasons in a little 1/8 acre hidey-hole plot where I hunt in West Tennessee. I planted it in the middle of September and disked it in with several bags of lime and fertilizer right before a good rain. Honey Hole had an almost 100% germination rate and grew very well. It was lush and green all through the season and we got turnips the size of baseballs from that plot. Be aware that this plot won’t be attractive to deer until you have a good, hard freeze or two, so plan accordingly.”
Includes both rapeseed and turnip
Easy to grow
Has a sweet taste and gives energy to bucks
May require approval from local authorities
Things To Consider When Choosing The Right Attractant
Before going to the store and buying deer attractant, there are some things you need to think through. This buying guide is created for you, as it will help you figure out which deer attractant to go for.
The Hunting Area
Different areas have different vegetation. So, when buying a deer attractant, think about what kind of food deer from your area prefer. If you purchase something that’s already growing in your region, you won’t see impressive results.
Instead, choose something that’s not that common in the area you live in. For example, deer that live in Southeastern states have access to enough forage all year long. Therefore, if you live in one of these states, it is better to use other kinds of attractants instead.
There are many different brands of deer attractants, so it’s usually hard to choose just one. Therefore, if you’re struggling to make the right decision, pay attention to the reviews on Amazon (and my reviews as well).
Types Of Attractants
Foods like corn, acorns, and brassicas are used all year round. They are high in nutrients and contain carbohydrates, fats, minerals, and protein. This diet helps deer to prepare for the winter.
Mineral attractants provide necessary minerals for deer to help them be healthy. It exists in liquid, powder, or granule form. Because this type of attractant is so rich in nutrients, deer usually come back for more.
Deer are very susceptible to scents, as it is the most developed sense they have. They usually come in the form of a spray or stick, and it is up to you which one you prefer.
Forms Of Attractants
This type of deer attractant, as you can guess, comes in a liquid form. They are usually referred to as scent attractants and have the odor of the real deer. However, there is a wide variety of scents if you’re not interested in this one, including apples, beets, etc.
This is simply mineral salt in the form of a block. This type of attractant is quite popular among animals, as they require salt and minerals in their diets.
These are mineral salts that have been crushed into powder form. They’re usually mixed with a food course, e.g., feed corn.
Tips For Using Deer Attractants
In order to get great results, soil testing is a critical step. The last thing you want is a plot fail due to the application of the wrong fertilizer. Keep in mind that acidic soils affect the growth of your plants as well. So, do a pH test before planting anything.
Don’t use attractants with the same aroma for a long time. Otherwise, deer will get used to it and will stop coming.
Consider which type of deer you want to lure; don’t just use a random attractant. Instead, do a little research to find out what will attract the specific type of deer you want.
Don’t forget to pay attention to the season. If the attractant you want to buy should be plotted in the summer and it’s already fall, look for an option that works all year round or during the fall. Otherwise, you won’t see any results.
In order to increase the chances of a successful hunt, use several methods of capturing a deer.
When going somewhere, make sure the attractants are stored in an appropriate place and not leaking. Just be overall careful with the products.
When using them, pay attention to the package directions, as not doing so will definitely lower your chances of luring a deer.
Pay attention to the wind direction and deer movement. It can either lower or increase your success rate because attractants depend on these factors.
And lastly, store them somewhere safe, so they stay fresh longer.
When you dig through the internet in order to find the best deer attractant, you are likely to stumble upon a wide variety. However, not all of them are going to do their job of luring bucks to your property.
Therefore, you should go through all the available options and investigate them before buying anything. Alternatively, you can skip the research part and just choose any of the products from the list above.
The chosen options are one hundred percent worth looking into before going for the next hunt. Make sure to plan carefully with the tips and products above.
I hope you found the best deer attractant for you. Have a good hunt!